UK Home Office loses fight to remove iCloud privacy in private court

I’m pleased the surveillance-loving UK Home Office has lost its attempt to make a huge decision that concerns every UK subject’s digital privacy behind closed doors with no scrutiny whatsoever.
This doesn’t mean the encryption push is over but does at least mean we’ll know what arguments are made to remove our privacy. It means that even if the government does get its way, at least we’ll get to consider its arguments for ourselves, and judge it accordingly.
The latest move toward authoritarianism concerns the now lengthy case between the UK and Apple concerning iCloud encryption.
Back doors can be found and will be broken
The UK wants to force Apple to insert some kind of backdoor into encrypted customer data, it had argued that discussing this in open court would threaten national security. The fact the decision also threatens digital privacy everywhere else just compounds the problem.
With its commitment to customer privacy and security, Apple has been fighting against this dumb demand. Likely because the company, like any sensible, digitally-savvy person outside the government recognizes the big threat to national security is the idea of a backdoor through encryption.
The way the UK wanted it would not even have seen that debate happen in public. The government had wanted to argue its merits in complete privacy.
The case went to the Investigatory Powers Tribunal today. The government argued that the merits of its demands should be held in a private court. Mercifully, the Tribunal decided the UK had failed to demonstrate that discussing the demand would damage national security.
Home Office security argument “fanciful”
This means the UK must now confirm it has served Apple with a technical capability notice (TCN) to compel it to make customer data accessible to security services, even when it is encrypted.
In its judgment, the tribunal said the combined effect was that anyone following the dispute already knew Apple had received a TCN. It described the suggestion that official acknowledgment would threaten national security or give a malicious actor fresh information as “fanciful.”
“We reject the respondent’s contention that it would be damaging to national security to confirm the fact that the respondent has given Apple a technical capability notice. The extent, if at all, to which some of the detail of the technical capability notice may be disclosed without damaging national security or the public interest is better addressed separately, after disclosure of evidence and when the precise issues to be determined at the hearing are clear.”
At least we’ll get to hear the argument
While this doesn’t mean the UK’s demand has been thrown out of court, it does at least mean its arguments across most parts of the case can be scrutinized by the UK public whose privacy is subject to this authoritarian information grab. In my view, it makes no one safer to make encryption weaker.
Now please subscribe to my daily, human-curated Apple-related news headline feed at The Core, or follow me on BlueSky, LinkedIn, or Mastodon.
